With this work we come to the summit of nietzsches attempts to do philosophy as art, to become anartisticsocrates as he had previously suggested doing in. This is one of the points in the poetics at which aristotles sensibility may seem shocking to us. And nietzsches long paragraphs have been broken into shorter units. The bloomsbury companion to existentialism is the definitive guide to this key area of modern european philosophy. However, if they do contest it, no great harm will be done. Philosophy, morality, tragedy ebook written by jeff love, jeffrey metzger. From notes from the underground, which thus falls on the border. The birth of tragedy, his first published work, is a classic text that remains an essential read for those seeking to understand the development of nietzsches ideas. A study on the development of crowdfunding in korean games through the success cases of star citizen lee, seung won, lee, kwang ho korea digital design council 2015 digital design studies vol. The first concerned the relationship between the tragic emotions, pity eleos and fear phobos, both being painful experiences, and the aesthetic result of the art of tragedy, the proper pleasure of tragedy he oikeia hedone tes tragodias. The philosophy of tragedy by no means seeks popularity or success. Although in his later philosophy nietzsche understands the saint as a representative of the ascetic ideal, nevertheless, this literature does not account for the shift that took place in nietzsches understanding of the saintly ideal and its significance. Nietzsche and dostoevsky northwestern university press. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders.
Teaching of tolstoy and nietzsche and the philosophy of tragedy, dostoevsky and nietzsche around the turn of the twentieth century, gives todays reader a picture of a nietzsche very foreign to our own nietzsches. Friedrich nietzsche stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. It deeply moves your heart to realize that the most downtrodden man, the lowest of the low, is also a human being, and is called your brother. Dostoevsky, kierkegaard, nietzsche, and kafka were all outsiders in their societies, unable to fit into the accepted nineteenthcentury categories of theology, philosophy, or belles lettres. He wrote critical texts on religion, morality, contemporary culture, philosophy, and science, displaying a fondness for metaphor, irony, and aphorism. The second begins with notes from the underground 1864 and ends with the pushkin speech 1880, that somber apotheosis of all dostoevsky s creative work. Philosophy, morality, tragedy studies in russian literature and theory. When nietzsche criticized aristotles views on tragedy in the birth of tragedy, he based his attack on two central issues. Friedrich nietzsche 1844 1900 friedrich wilhelm nietzsche 15 october 1844 25 august 1900 was a german philosopher, poet, composer, cultural critic, and classical philologist. Dostoevsky, kierkegaard, nietzsche and kafka by william hubben. Dostoevsky was raised in the russian orthodox church and considered his. Indeed, if it is a similarity of inner experience rather than a common origin, a common place of residence, and a similarity of character that binds people together and makes them kindred, then nietzsche and dostoevsky can without exaggeration be called brothers, even twins. These words fully express the idea for the sake of which dostoevsky first embarked on his literary career.
For possibly the first time in russian literature, these two great thinkers of the nineteenth century dostoevsky and nietzsche were brought into a comparative discussion, subjected to a critical analysis and evaluated on a single. The philosophy of tragedy 1903 is among the earlier works written by russian philosopher lev shestov. Nietzsche explicitly acknowledged dostoevsky s relevance to his work, noting its affinities as well as its points of opposition. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading nietzsche and dostoevsky. Dostoevsky the philosopher presents himself dostoevsky hasnt just become famous as a literary artist, but also as a kind of thinker.
The philosophy of tragedy 1903 is among the earlier works written by russian philosopher. From plato to z i z ek the focal question has been. Dostoevsky and nietzsche the philosophy of tragedy. Mikhail dostoevsky and maria dostoevskaya born nechayeva. Nietzsche announced the death of god, whereas dostoevsky warned against the danger of atheism. Fyodor dostoyevsky, in full fyodor mikhaylovich dostoyevsky, dostoyevsky also spelled dostoevsky, born november 11 october 30, old style, 1821, moscow, russiadied february 9 january 28, old style, 1881, st. The productive conflict of art and philosophy in thus.
Dostoevsky speaks of the regeneration of his convictions. Philosophy, morality, tragedy studies in russian literature and theory by love, jeff, metzger, jeffrey isbn. Nietzsche explicitly acknowledged dostoevskys relevance to his work, noting its affinities as well as its points of opposition. For questions, suggestions, corrections, and so on please contact ian johnston friedrich nietzsche the birth of tragedy an attempt at self.
Friedrich nietzsche developed his philosophy during the late 19th century. Instead, they saw themselves both as the end products of a dying civilization and as prophets of the coming chaos of. He celebrated life and stressed that the secret of the greatest enjoyment is to live dangerously and intensely. As an ethical guide, raskolnikov might serve nietzscheans everywhere as an example of the dangers of breaking the old tablets. The apotheosis of groundlessness 19055which increased his reputation. Philosophy of tragedy is a profound analysis of the nature of tragedy in these. But dostoevsky and nietzsche spoke, and they had a right to speak, in the name of the underground people no one, of course, will contest this, not even those who are unwilling to reckon with their views. If we take this circumstance into account, it will probably not seem strange that nietzsche held such a high opinion of dostoevsky. This is an introduction to one of nietzsches most important works a key text in nineteenthcentury philosophy. Friedrich nietzsche 18441900 was a german philosopher and cultural critic who published intensively in the 1870s and 1880s. Dostoevsky, the problem of evil philosophy home page. Philosophy, morality, tragedy studies in russian literature and theory kindle edition by love, jeff, metzger, jeffrey. He is famous for uncompromising criticisms of traditional european morality and religion, as well as of conventional philosophical ideas and social and political pieties associated with modernity. Both of them are credited with laying much of the foundation for what came to be called existentialist thought.
The birth of tragedy 1871 human, too human 1878 the wanderer and his shadow 1880. Shestovs nietzsche is a literary figure, a profoundly irrationalist thinker who does not have much to offer us in the way of. After more than a century, the urgency with which the writing of fyodor dostoevsky and friedrich nietzsche speaks to us is undiminished. Greek drama tragedy history and criticism theory, etc. In in this lecture, i explore fyodor dostoevskys piece, notes from the underground, examining some of the key philosophical themes introduced, the. Of course, that was dostoevsky s idea of the real psychological consequences of committing a senseless murder. Is it possible that he would decide to offer the public the dull and monotonous story of the horrors he had to experience. In twilight of the idols, he calls him the only psychologist from whom i had something to learn, and there are more oblique references elsewhere. Or does philosophy also have its flowers and poetry, which also constitute its raison detre.
Following the chronological thread offered by nietzsches correspondence, the author provides a detailed analysis of nietzsches engagement with dostoevsky from the very. The birth of tragedy, his first published work, is a classic text that remains an essential read for those seeking to understand the development of nietzsche s ideas. Dostoevskys literary work can be divided into two periods. Dostoevskys crime and punishment, then, can be a valuable book for those considering and evaluating nietzsches philosophy.
Readings of dostoevsky in dostoevsky and nietzsche. Philosophy, morality, tragedy after more than a century, the urgency with which the writing of fyodor dostoevsky and friedrich nietzsche speaks to us is undiminished. You can find out more about him and other great thinkers in our great thinkers book. Philosophy, morality, tragedy studies in russian literature and theory ebook. This book describes the double encounter between nietzsche and dostoevsky. The story has been considered as one of the foreground works of the philosophical. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read nietzsche and dostoevsky.
Shestovdostoevsky and nietzsche the philosophy of tragedy scribd. The productive conflict of art and philosophy in thus spoke. Nietzche is known to have read a number of dostoevskys novels in french in the late 1880s, though i dont know whether crime and punishment specifically was among them. Friedrich nietzsche was arguably the most important and influential thinker of the nineteenth century. Dostoevsky is a human one, and the question of man is a divine one. Influenced as it was by romanticism and schopenhauer, the birth of tragedy elevates art to the highest importance. The translator has added occasional editorial inserts to help clarify some foreign terms.
Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Read download existentialism from dostoevsky to sartre pdf. Dostoevsky, tolstoy, and nietzsche by shestov, lev, 18661938. Now available in paperback, the book covers the fundamental questions asked by existentialism, providing valuable guidance for students and researchers to some of the many important and enduring contributions of existentialist thinkers. What made the book so controversial when it first appeared in 1872 was nietzsches strange account of the birth and death of greek tragedy. Dostoevsky s literary work can be divided into two periods. Shestovdostoevsky and nietzsche the philosophy of tragedy free download as open office file. Notes from underground is the first of dostoevskys works which has been given a wide philosophical acceptance. It is often assumed that the main assertions of the birth of tragedy about the apollonian, the dionysian, and more generally the function of art, rest on an implicit core of schopenhauerian metaphysics, which nietzsche would later have criticised and rejected1. Nietzche is known to have read a number of dostoevsky s novels in french in the late 1880s, though i dont know whether crime and punishment specifically was.
Nietzsches critique of aristotles theory of tragic. Creating and resolving existential despair geoff uyleman geoff uyleman is a senior at brigham young university majoring in philosophy. Nietzsche, cosmodicy, and the saintly ideal philosophy. And is this science of sciences also an art the art of passing off various interesting and entertaining things as truth. This is an outstanding collection of scholarship on the connections and disconnections of two fascinating and massively influential writers. This is an introduction to one of nietzsche s most important works a key text in nineteenthcentury philosophy.
Why, in spite of its distressing content, do we value tragic drama. Nietzsche, and as lucretius and spinoza drew a philosophy of joy, creativity and wholeness vital. This page features a growing list of free philosophy ebooks, presenting essential works by aristotle, hegel, kant, nietzsche, wittgenstein and many other philosophers. The philosophy of tragedy, the third book of the russian philosopher, published in 1901 in diaghilevs famous magazine the world of art, then in volume in 1903, was soon translated into eight languages and will have the highest number of editions. Philosophy, morality, tragedy studies in russian literature and theory love, jeff, metzger, jeffrey on. Nietzsche believed that the central task of philosophy was to teach us to become who we are. After graduating in 2005, he hopes to continue his career in the information technology and services industry. But it is well to remember that nahum tate 16521715, who was an english poet laureate, rewrote the ending of king lear in. Scanlan, author of dostoevsky the thinker these engaging and powerfully written essays contribute a variety of new perspectives about the shared legacy of nietzsche and dostoevsky as tragic analysts and prophets of the modern condition. Pdf readings of nietzsche in dostoevsky and nietzsche. The philosophy of tragedy lev shestov, bernard martin, spencer roberts on.
He was raised in the family home in the grounds of the mariinsky hospital for the poor, which was in a lower class district on the edges of moscow. How four of europes most mysterious and fascinating writers shaped the modern mind. Dostoevsky s crime and punishment, then, can be a valuable book for those considering and evaluating nietzsche s philosophy. The philosophy of tragedy from plato to z i z ek this book is a comprehensive survey of the philosophy of tragedy from antiquity to the present. Instead, they saw themselves both as the end products of a dying civilization and as prophets of the. Nietzsche, for instance, would probably not agree that a freely chosen act, even a murder, would necessarily plunge a person into an abyss of guilt. Nietzsche gives art a crucial role in his philosophy. Dostoevsky, tolstoy, and nietzsche the good in the teaching of. The first begins with poor folk 1845 and ends with the house of the dead 18611862.
Shestovs use of nietzsche in his interpretation of tolstoy and dostoevsky lev shestov wrote two books whose titles contain a refererence to nietzsche. Aug 31, 2012 in in this lecture, i explore fyodor dostoevsky s piece, notes from the underground, examining some of the key philosophical themes introduced, the character of the underground man, and what we. Petersburg, russian novelist and shortstory writer whose psychological penetration into the darkest recesses of the human heart, together with his unsurpassed moments of. Nietzsche recognized dostoevsky as a kindred spirit. This book begins with a short section on tolstoy, and then continues with larger ones on dostoevsky and nietzsche.
The mantle of the prophet by james wood for the new republic, reprinted by powells books. From a filthy barracks room in siberia, fyodor dostoevsky begged his brother michael to send him what he called absolutely necessary intellectual food. Oct 10, 2014 nietzsche believed that the central task of philosophy was to teach us to become who we are. The second begins with notes from the underground 1864 and ends with the pushkin speech 1880, that somber apotheosis of all dostoevskys creative work. Instead, they saw themselves both as the end products of a dying civilization pdf and as prophets of the coming chaos of the twentieth century.
1194 943 428 652 22 1263 1029 374 223 1258 1121 143 1532 1130 1243 360 723 567 194 342 1302 1270 871 859 329 376 1033 1079 1016 1019 371 501 238 1440 155 1189 324